Article book review Books and Culture Family Fashion Featured Item Karl Ove Knausgaard My Struggle Show on Homepage

Life from All Sides | Dissent Magazine

Life from All Sides | Dissent Magazine

Life from All Sides

On the coronary heart of Knausgaard’s wrestle is the potential for understanding—between himself and his household, himself and his readers.

Ana Isabel Keilson ▪ Winter 2019
Karl Ove Knausgård on the metropolis library in Lund, Sweden, 2010. (Photograph by Robin Linderborg)

Seasons Quartet
by Karl Ove Knausgaard
Penguin Press, 2017–18


Close to the top of Leo Tolstoy’s Anna Karenina, Dolly, the mannequin of a faithful spouse and mom, travels to go to her sister-in-law, Anna, who resides in scandal on a rustic property together with her lover Vronsky. As Dolly watches the Russian countryside cross by from the carriage window, “all of the ideas she had repressed crowded abruptly into her thoughts, and she or he reviewed her entire life from all sides as she had by no means accomplished earlier than.” Musing on subjects from the mundane (her youngsters’s consuming habits and wardrobes) to the mortal (the dying of a son in infancy), Dolly finds herself questioning the forces that had ruled her fifteen years of married life. “It’s all so incomprehensible and troublesome,” she thinks. “And what’s all of it for? What is going to come of all of it?” Dolly arrives at no definitive conclusions, persevering with in her home roles as earlier than. But her questions linger, by no means removed from her—or the reader’s—thoughts.

Current work by the Norwegian author Karl Ove Knausgaard may be learn as an try to look at a “entire life from all sides.” What for Dolly took form as a four-hour respite from child-rearing has for Knausgaard turn into a number of books, together with the six My Wrestle novels. Within the first two volumes, Knausgaard paperwork a panorama of encounters and objects (household dinners, cassette tapes, Rembrandt), his relationship together with his abusive father, his two marriages, and the delivery of his first three youngsters. In volumes three, 4, and 5, there are extra household dinners, white Nikes, and Flaubert; we study his childhood, sexual awakening, wrestle with alcoholism, and ambition to turn out to be a author. The ultimate quantity charts the publication and reception of the primary e-book, together with a lawsuit filed by an uncle, sad with the portrayal of a brother. The collection programs alongside for almost four,000 pages, but Knausgaard’s readability of voice and his compulsive, convulsive consideration to element signifies that nothing feels repetitive.

In Knausgaard’s writing, the household is the supply from which life flows, giving it type and content material whereas limiting its risk and scope. It is sensible that Tolstoy is considered one of his heroes. Household defines the characters in Conflict and Peace and Anna Karenina, novels that map politics and historical past alongside the arc of childhood, motherhood, and fatherhood. Tolstoy himself had 13 youngsters, and a fraught relationship together with his spouse. When Dolly realizes that her youngsters give life its form and substance, it leads her to query the which means of her social position. Knausgaard’s central wrestle emerges from an analogous course of. The extra he locates himself inside the household, the extra he discovers the purpose the place the completely uninteresting (diapers, mealtimes, laundry) merges with life and dying. The extra he realizes this, the extra he’s topic to his household’s calls for, extra firmly entrenched in his position as father and husband.

Knausgaard’s descriptions, like Anselm Kiefer’s oils, represent a seek for “depth in surfaces.”

If the six My Wrestle volumes present Knausgaard coming to phrases with these recognitions and restrictions, the Seasons Quartet exhibits one other aspect of those tensions. For as a lot as household limits Knausgaard’s life, it additionally permits him to see energy in a brand new approach.

The Quartet is framed as a collection of letters, journal entries, and vignettes addressed to his fourth and youngest daughter. She is in utero in Autumn, born halfway by means of Winter, three months previous in Spring, and a toddler in Summer time. Most of the chapters are solely a web page or so lengthy. All volumes function illustrations all through the textual content, which provide content material in addition to type. In a single episode in Summer time, for instance, Knausgaard pays a studio go to to Anselm Kiefer to pick work for the guide; Knausgaard observes how the artist achieves with shade and visible type the sense of time and proximity he searches for with phrases. “For that was what I skilled in Kiefer’s work, the totally different velocities of time within the materials and within the human world, and a continuing seek for depth in surfaces, which is the curse of each painter however with Kiefer appears to be an obsession.”

Knausgaard’s descriptions, like Kiefer’s oils, represent a seek for “depth in surfaces” that within the Quartet excavates the causes and origins of issues. To do that, Knausgaard should strip himself of recurring methods of seeing and considering: “And the duty of artwork is to see one thing because it actually is, as if for the primary time.” Who however a child sees on this means? For Knausgaard, to be a father is to be an observer, a task that provides urgency and function to his writing. The duty to explain the world to his daughter turns into a strategy of de-familiarization with a purpose to make sense of life.

The world is filled with issues in want of rationalization. In Autumn and Winter, Knausgaard describes every little thing from blood (“Like every little thing else discovered contained in the physique, with the partial exception of the mind, the blood doesn’t know what it’s doing”); cash (“Our entire society is constructed across the perception within the fiction of cash, and the second that perception vanishes, society collapses”); and toothbrushes (“[the children] are at pains to say their property rights over every little thing that’s theirs and don’t permit anybody to make use of any of their possessions with out prior permission [. . .] but they’re detached to possession with regards to toothbrushes”); to ideas like “the I” (“The distinctive factor about life, what distinguishes it radically from non-life, dwelling matter from lifeless matter, is will. A stone needs nothing, a blade of grass needs one thing”) and “the native” (“And maybe that’s how we should always think about the universe, not as one thing alien and summary, all these dizzying numbers and huge distances, however as one thing close by and acquainted”). In every case, Knausgaard strikes from elemental description to an account of use and circulation on the planet. Objects aren’t merely materials—they’re cultural and social, too.


Seasons shortly change, like lives and literary type. In Spring, the catalogue of issues provides method to a steady narrative that lasts simply over at some point. There’s a purpose for this. Early on within the e-book, Knausgaard describes to his daughter a gathering with Youngster Safety Providers, one yr earlier than her delivery. “It was a routine assembly, they all the time organized one when it occurred, the factor that had occurred right here, nevertheless it didn’t depart me unaffected . . .” Knausgaard, in his mid-forties, describes his disgrace as he solutions questions posed by two younger social staff.

What was it, “the factor that had occurred right here”? Like a photograph in a darkroom, particulars regularly come into sight. Knausgaard writes to his daughter that they’re going to go to her mom, who’s within the hospital. There are descriptions of associates and acquaintances who’ve tried and dedicated suicide. There are descriptions of his spouse’s melancholy and her wrestle, their wrestle, to get assist.

Life, just like the cruelest season, marches on. Knausgaard and his daughter go to the ATM, run errands, decide up the opposite youngsters from faculty. As the image of their household life develops, the quotidian blurs with the philosophical. Knausgaard’s process to elucidate the world to a child turns into a activity to elucidate why life is value dwelling. What’s all of it for? What is going to develop into of it? Solutions are buried inside minor fights, disagreements, day by day routines, frustrations between mother and father and youngsters, brother and sister, father or mother and mother or father. There are occasions, Knausgaard explains,

when emotions obtained uncontrolled, a sequence response may happen through which [my children’s] actions snagged on mine and eventually made me explode in methods I hadn’t skilled since I personally was a toddler, when my imaginative and prescient might all of a sudden cloud with anger. Even once we have been amongst different individuals I typically misplaced my mood utterly. As soon as I roared THAT’S ENOUGH! THAT’S ENOUGH! to your elder sister in the midst of a purchasing centre, she was perhaps two and a half years previous, and I slung her over my shoulder and carried her like a sack out to the road whereas she screamed and kicked and I fumed inwardly. Clearly individuals stared, I allow them to stare, I used to be in a spot the place different individuals and their opinions didn’t matter.

Within the indignant contest of mum or dad versus youngster, brute pressure wins. But what’s most fascinating about this passage is the best way that Knausgaard questions the legitimacy of his personal actions as he narrates them. What are his grounds for disciplining his daughter? A collection of “snagged” feelings, emotions let unfastened, a imaginative and prescient “clouded with anger”? It isn’t exhausting to acknowledge that the grownup is the one behaving badly.

If there’s any sort of lesson discovered on this episode, and even all through the ebook—and Knausgaard is fast to admit his missteps to the reader—it’s that what shapes our engagement with others is all the time one thing much less mediated than we understand.


Spring ends, and Summer time begins. Returning to the format of Autumn and Winter, Summer time has entries on family home equipment, in style tradition, and ice cream. However one thing is totally different. It’s unattainable to learn Summer time—the bike rides at nightfall, neighborhood BBQs, the infinite parade of afterschool actions—with out “the factor that occurred right here” in thoughts. Although his tone and elegance keep the identical, Knausgaard marks a shift in his personal considering by adopting the persona of a lady, based mostly on an actual acquaintance of his grandfather in the course of the Second World Warfare, a way harking back to his second novel, A Time for Every part, a retelling of biblical tales from a number of views. Caught in a loveless marriage with a number of youngsters, the lady has an affair with a German soldier stationed in Sweden, a selection that results in violence and troubling penalties. (The importance of Kiefer’s work, typically taken to characterize Germany’s reckoning with the Nazi previous, right here takes on added cost.) Knausgaard’s ideas merge with hers, and her story and its darkish conclusion wind into his diary entries and vignettes. The result’s a lyrical and disorienting interiority.

For the lady, the injury she does to her household damages her in return. “The lady I’m writing about is aware of what she has achieved and displays upon it; whereas she has forgiven herself, she has not been capable of forestall it from ruining her life.” This strategy of coming to phrases together with her previous allows Knausgaard to know the consequences of his personal motion, and inaction, on these nearest him. It additionally provides him purpose to pause.

Although, how can a life be ruined? In relation to what? [ . . . ] To reconcile oneself with one’s destiny, the expression goes, and it means simply this: understanding that life seems the best way it does, that nothing can ever be redone, that there isn’t any different path to be taken than this one, which ends the second you die and, because it have been, draw the ladder up after your self. It’s a thought I discover comforting. We do the most effective we will.

However what, we’d nonetheless fairly ask, is it for? In any case, Knausgaard’s venture is nothing new: quite a lot of modern writers have handled the trimmings of life with youngsters and the wrestle to reconcile the calls for of domesticity with the imperatives of writing and art-making. Authors corresponding to Rachel Cusk, Heidi Julavits, and Sheila Heti depict the household as an area sealed off from politics and artwork—it’s a supply of hysteria, distraction, impossibility. Different writers, similar to Maggie Nelson, Elena Ferrante, and Knausgaard, present the household as a path to the broader world. For them, it’s a fertile floor for contest and deliberation, the place its members practice themselves within the messy actuality of political battle.

On the coronary heart of Knausgaard’s wrestle is the potential of understanding—between himself and his household, himself and his readers. This understanding comes by means of the stripping aside of objects and buildings, the peeling away of surfaces for depth, the examination of life from all sides. Although Knausgaard arrives at no definitive conclusions, he is able to see energy in a brand new mild. What he’ll do with this vantage level stays in his arms, for him to do the most effective he can.

Ana Isabel Keilson is a lecturer on Social Research at Harvard College. She is at present writing a e-book on politics, tradition, and trendy dance in Germany.

fbq(‘init’, ‘552845971584446’,
em: ‘insert_email_variable,’
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);
(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); = id;
js.src = “//join.fb.internet/en_US/all.js#xfbml=1&appId=214067098624442”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));

About the author